Wednesday, 17 January 2024

Three 1870 inventions

 

Edison and his phonograph

In the 1870s three revolutionary technologies shook the world and changed it forever :

1876 : telephone

1877 : phonograph

1879: electric light bulb

All were basically leap-frog innovations, but based on existing science and technology.

The contrasting impact of the three were fascinating.

Phonographs which earned Edison the moniker Wizard of Menlo Park, completely stalled, because amplifiers were bad, duplication was not possible, etc. That problem was solved 20 years later by invention of the triode (ironically inspired by Edison’s electric bulb).

Telephones revolutioninzed business, government, industry, banking and military, but took nearly forty years to become consumer goods.

The electric light was utterly transformational across every facet of society. Until Edison’s light bulb, electricity was also mainly industrial or business oriented. Heavy magnets at harbours and factories, and the telegraph were the only public benefits of electricity until then.

Edisons light bulb changed all this. It brought electricity into every urban home and office within 20 years in most of the West.

It became a platform for a whole horde of technologies as transformational as the steam engine earlier, and transparent glass even earlier.

Electricity’s impact was rivalled only by the arrival of petrol/diesel engine cars, also invented in the 1870s but which had no or very low impact for nearly 25 years.

Electric cars, trains, buses all came into use, around this era, but were of poor quality and not very widespread. They were all overtaken by petrol based vehicles by 1920 or so and electric vehicles did not challenge petrol/diesel vehicles until Elon Musk’s Tesla transformed the industry in the 2010s. Henry Ford actually worked in Edison’s electric companies, rising quickly to Chief Engineer, before quitting to revolutionise petrol based cars and make them widespread.

Edison's telephone: Picture from Internet


The triode, born out of the diode, invented by Ambrose Fleming (more famous for Fleming’s left hand rule), was discovered to be an amplifier of current, which became very useful for radios, invented shortly afterwards. Then the triode amplifier became useful to amplify the sound in phonographs. Edison’s original tin drum phonograph did not take off, but Zenophile Gramme invented the flat disk version, now popularly called gramophones. By 1910 mass manufacturing of gramophones combined with amplification to make the sound output of gramophone, made them explode in popuarity – nearly two decades after Edison and Gramme’s inventions. I suspect Edison himself had switched over to focusing his efforts on the light bulb – and after it the development of the entire electrical system, primarily because the phonograph evoked more wonder than sales.

The telephone itself, was also improved by Edison, especially by addition of  a battery, providing a stable current rather than using a windup mechanism to power the transmission of electricity across telephone lines. Alexander Graham Bell’s company AT&T, bought Edison’s phones to sell to their customers – became more the telephone exchange rather than equipment manufacturer.

Ironically phonographs/gramophones succeded in the one field Edison did not imagine at all – recorded music. Again ironically, Edison worked on the cinematograph and movie making, but again failed to understand what entertainment would be popular. The movie making world ran away from New York, where Edison was based, to California – too far even by train – to escape Edison’s attempts to monopolize the field.

It is fascinating how the three inventions panned out. Rarely is their comparative history narrated together.

But the phonograph, lightbulb, electrification, (and also triode, radio, airplane etc.) were inventions that did not come from the learned halls of brilliant academics with doctorates in philosophy or from the wise poets and artists who bore on their shoulders the learning of a hundred previous generations, but basically the most uneducated/ self-educated, hyper motivated, relentless, incredibly ingenious people like Edison, Ford, Benz, Daimler, Westinghouse, Lee de forest, Fessenden, etc.

Thorstein Veblen, the economist, predicted in 1899 that engineers would run the world , because they were the only people who understood how everything worked.

He was wrong, IMHO. Most engineers don't understand people or money.


Inventors and Discoverers


2 comments:

  1. Really? Did the movie industry move to California to escape Edison's attempt at monopoly or is that ur conjecture?
    Becos I've never heard of this till now.

    Yes the comparison is v interesting becos, a complex combination of factors seem to influence the fate of inventions - just like movies - rather unpredictable.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They also wanted the sunny climate of California and the cheap land in the then undeveloped Los Angeles, but Edison was a major factor.

      Delete