Showing posts with label Microsoft. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Microsoft. Show all posts

Wednesday, 18 June 2025

My interview with Elon Musk

In 1999, I was between jobs. For nearly five years I had worked at Microsoft in Redmond (which is a suburb of Seattle). It rains eight months a year in Seattle, so it is one of the most beautiful cities in the world, with several lakes, always filled with water, breathtakingly green with trees everywhere, with dazzling colours in autumn, and mild winters for a city that far north – only in 1996 was there heavy snow. There are two snowcapped mountain ranges to the East and West of Seattle, called the Cascades and the Olympics respectively, and a magnificent volcano called Mt Rainier about 70miles south, which was an awesome sight on clear days. It never rained heavily in Seattle, only mild drizzles.

Microsoft was mostly a wonderful place to work, and I was astounded that I even got a job there in 1994, barely four years after reading about in the small library at my college in Srivilliputtur. The campus was beautiful, the software work was interesting and quite different than what I imagined, but by 1999, I was probably saturated, though not quite burnt out. But I was perhaps very depressed in 1999, not realizing it then, perhaps because of the weather. Ten to twelve hours of looking at a computer screen, is probably terrible for the human psyche, even with

But it was an exciting time in software, and the computer industry, because the Internet had exploded with Netscape’s browser and a few websites in 1995. The internet really started taking off in 1997. Coincidentally that was the year cellphones also became affordable. Most of the action was in Silicon Valley, in San Jose and Sunnyvale and Mountain View and Palo Alto and the various suburbs south of San Francisco. By 1999, I was reading news and essays from several websites, some of newspapers others of e-magazines. Two prominent websites were Slate and Salon. Slate was run by Microsoft, most of its staff was in Buiding E, in Redmond West campus, where I was working in the MSN group.

In August, Microsoft fired me (the official reason was that I was not good at writing software) and  after having no luck looking for jobs in Seattle, I decided to look for a job in the San Francisco Bay Area. I was also trying to write screenplays because I had become interested in screenwriting, both for movies and for TV. I even attended a screenwriters conference in LA in 1998. I sent out spec scripts to agents, which produced no responses. I was staying at a friend’s house in San Jose, when I read an essay/interview in Salon.com about a guy called Elon Musk, who had just sold his software company to Compaq, a major PC manufacturing company. He had bought a McLaren street model car (similar to a Formula 1 car, but a version which you can drive on city roads and highways). I was an F-1 fan then, so this fascinated me. Musk  was my age and he had already sold his company for 300 million dollars. The interview mentioned he was starting a new company, called X.com and it had his email address. As a lark, I sent him an email with my resume and asked for a job (I am almost never this enterprising).

Yes. Elon Musk in 1999 was planning to start a company called X.com, 25 years before he bought Twitter and renamed it X (now in 2024). This was before he even started Tesla or SpaceX.

Surprisingly, I got a response to my email inviting me to a coffee shop in Palo Alto a day later. So I went and met him. He was friendly and genial, and spoke in that same series of staccato sentences, that you see now on TV or youtube. He talked about his company, but I had no idea what his business plan was. He explained, I just didn’t understand. I had just recently read a book called “The Lexus and the Olive Tree” by Thomas Friedman, a New York Times journalist, and I had realized I knew almost nothing about the business world or finance or economics. After five years working for perhaps the world’s most famous business at that time, I felt ridiculously ignorant about money.

It was also perhaps the worst time in the history of the human race to learn about money or economics or business, because at that time, every company was trying to do everything for FREE. I had no idea where any company’s revenue would come from. The two internet company crashes in 2000 and 2001/2002 suggest that most of the venture capitalists who invested in these companies, and even those who managed or worked in these companies, had no idea where they money would come from, either. They just ran out of capital, before raking in revenue.

Musk got his coffee, I got hot chocolate, and then basically he described the job he was hiring for. It was basically managing a software team, most of the work would be testing software that the company developed. Some of it would be developing in-house tools and some probably acquiring software from other companies. Software companies spend 90% of their software effort in testing software and only 10% in actual development. Even software developers spend more than half their time fixing bugs in software that they or others wrote. Now, I had five years of software development and testing experience, but only two years was in the internet division, and they had lower standards than boxed software like Microsoft Windows or Office or SQL Server – software products that were common before the internet. And I had no experience at all buying software or even evaluating it. And I had very little experience hiring people – I had only interviewed a few candidates for hiring at Microsoft. Even as he was speaking, I realized Musk was looking for someone two levels above me. This was not suprising. Company founders look to hire top level people, not low level developers, except a very few brilliant people. So, I leaned backwards, understanding that I was underqualified for the job.

Nothing special so far. But the next few minutes have haunted me. Not immediately, but about five years later. Because while I thought the interview ended, and the disappointment in my face obvious, but hopefully not too melancholy, Musk kept talking. He didn’t finish his coffee, he was just sipping it, I had barely sipped my drink either. And he talked about several aspects of what he was visualising. Some of it was abstract and way over my head, some of it was concrete and I could grasp some of it (I don’t remember any of it). But I didn’t get an overall picture. I vaguely think it was some sort of money related software, but much more than that. But I had no real understanding of what it was. I had interviewed with several other dotcoms at this time: Calpurnia, Yodlee, Decide, PartsRiver, are some of the names I remember; for a few months I worked for decide.com, before quitting software and returning to India.

Musk just kept talking, sometimes smiling, sometimes serious. I had dismissed myself as a candidate but he hadn’t. I suspect he liked something about me, and was just hoping I would say something like, “Look just hire me now and we will figure out what I can do later.” He was looking for someone who was willing to take a career risk (after all I had emailed him, which was taking a chance). But I am not that kind of risk taker, I suppose. I also think he had some great idea for software and he just wanted to explain to a fellow geek and share the excitement, without revealing much. If I figured out what he described, he would have offered me a job.

Remember, he was not famous then. I didn’t know what Musk was hinting at.  He would go on to build PayPal, but I don’t think that’s what he described to me. PayPal is easy enough to understand. It seems that he joined PayPal and took over. According to Wikipedia, Musk had founded a banking company called X.com, which he merged with Paypal, and ran it for sometime, before Peter Thiel took over. Paypal became extremely succesful, becoming the first paymetnt alternative to credit cards and electronic transfer from brick and mortar banks. Musk started SpaceX from the money he cashed in from Paypal, and revolutionized rocket launches. And later he joined and then took over Tesla, and revolutionized the car industry.

I have no regrets that Musk didn’t hire me – I don’t know if I would have been successful. I also realized I was bored of the software industry after I returned to India, and didn’t miss writing software. I was perhaps burnt out.

1999 in my Seattle apartment

My only other encounter with a global celebrity was perhaps a sideline chat with Bill Gates at a Microsoft developer in conference in Bellevue. This was a internal company conference, for software developers, in 1996 I think. Some demos, some discussion of general strategy, but mostly a full day of talks by executives and software experts. During lunch and tea breaks, several of the star developers and execs were surrounded, mostly by fresh hires or those who really wanted to be heard. Gates was surrounded by three rings of developers, and he was hotly debating a few of them who thought Microsoft should switch to Java or something different in the Internet space. Microsoft was the most admired company by investors and most engineers outside the USA and somewhat feared but totally hated by competitors in the USA. I snatched the chance at a pause to ask him a technical question, and he dismissed it as not significant.

All my other interviews in the software industry were far less dramatic. I don’t think anyone else has become a global celebrity. Anyway, I thought this encounter might interest some readers of my blog, though not much happened.

Links


Thursday, 9 April 2020

Modi’s Lights Out – and a signalling challenge to end the lockdown


In 1999, I was working for the MSN team in Microsoft, and decided I wanted to look for opportunities in a different group. My boss Brad Thomson, said ok, and allowed me to look for other jobs within Microsoft.  I was interested in a job as a programmer or developer – designation Software Design Engineer.  At that time, the hiring group still conducted multiple interviews where I had to demonstrate my skills in programming, analytical thinking, problem solving, and communication.

Seattle days - 1999, in my apartment
I actually enjoyed the interview processes. I interviewed with four different groups. It was challenging, very different, and exposed some gaps in my abilities and knowledge. Some of the interview questions were easy, some were hard, some were above my level. I realized I didn’t want to join one of those groups, I failed badly in one set of interviews, and I did moderately well in the other two. Oddly the head of the group where I failed badly, called me for a personal interview where he grilled me with a software challenge, which I passed. Then he offered me a different job, which I didn’t take. Eventually I wallowed in the MSN group, then I was fired (for incompetence at programming) and went on to a dotcom company in California. I realized that I was really bored of software, and so quit and returned to India. Also, at that time, I had a deep interest in writing, especially screenwriting, I missed my dad and my family, I missed India and so on.

But what remained with me from the Microsoft interviews were two things. In one of the interviews I failed, the interviewer expressed enormous passion for writing software; he waxed eloquent about what new things he could do with code,what the new internet paradigms, object oriented code, and some software and hardware novelties promised. He made me realize that I simply wasn’t that excited about software or even computers, at that point. After a few months in the California company I realized that a career in computers was an intellectual and creative dead end for me, even though the financial prospects in the software industry were quite excellent. (Actually, the big dotcom crash happened shortly after I returned to India, but by that time it was irrelevant to me).

The other interview question is the soul of this essay. This was the problem set by the interviewer: “There is a long line of soldiers standing along a hill. The line starts at the base of one side of the hill, continues over the hill and out of sight and ends at the base of the other side. None of them has watches or clocks. The commander tells his soldiers that on his signal all the soldiers must fire their guns simultaneously. But not immediately after the signal. They must develop a signalling mechanism among themselves, so that all of them, even the ones on the other side must fire. The critical aspect is that they all fire simultaneously.”

You might wonder what this has to do with computers or software or Microsoft. Also this seems like one bizarre army unit and weird commander. But this is not an unusual question in the software industry. The problem is signalling. A computer system problem may involve one hundred printers connected to a single main computer, all of which have to start printing simultaneously. Or a controlling computer in a sports stadium, where all the lights must be turned on or off simultaneously. Or coordinating a bunch of satellites in space, thousands of miles apart, which must perform a synchronized action, like photograph a nova. The solution is an algorithm that solves this signalling problem.

Lights out

The interview question relates also to Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s two requests to the public, first to assemble in our balconies at 5pm on March 23 and clap for the medical and other public servants who were fighting the CoronaVirus, and then to switch off electric lights and light candles or oil lamps or cellphones for nine minutes at 9pm on April 5. A huge section of India’s population did both. There are two aspects. One is broadcast communication to almost the entire. This was not possible twenty years ago, when most Indians didn’t have television, only some had cable TV, dish antennas were new, cellphones were new, the internet was in its early stages, and smartphones had not been invented. Narasimha Rao or Vajpayee could not have communicated to so many people.


Modi lights a lamp - April 5
Even the poorest Indians lit lamps

The second aspect is synchronicity. Ubiquity of cellphones means now everyone has a clock. In the 1800s the British army at Fort St George in Madras (and presumably the forts in Bombay and Calcutta) fired a cannon, at 8am and 8pm everyday – hence the phrase gun-time. In several places across the world, clock towers were installed. Temple bells served this function in pre-Colonial India, though not everywhere.

So we had a whole country lighting lamps, clapping, ringing bells, banging on plates and pots in unison, all solving my Microsoft interview question in  a national light and sound show. But you had people acting according to their wishes, assembling in groups, not maintaining minimal physical distance, etc., all of which were severely lampooned. We already had incidents of bad coordination, when bus stands were crowded, huge numbers of people had to walk hundreds of miles to hometowns, people crowded ration shops. People abused even simple mechanisms like circles to stand in, by putting their bags or markers there, missing the whole point.

Wrong way to maintain social distance
May be just avoiding the heat
The right way to maintain social distance
Villagers show the way

But civilians are like that, they are independent actors not a disciplined force like an army. Consider that soldiers spend about four years practicing marching, before they get it right. Just getting a thousand people to walk together takes years of training, practice, discipline and punishment.

But India (and the world) now has a few more questions and signalling issues like this to deal with, once the national lockdown is lifted. Most probably only certain sectors of the economy and the public will be allowed to come out and do some things. Currently in my home state, Tamilnadu, pharmacies are the only shops allowed to be open all day long. Grocery stores and vegetable shops are allowed to open in the mornings. Some restaurants are open, but only for pick up or delivery, not for dining at the restaurants. In the next few weeks, different categories of shops, like electrical equipment suppliers, hardware stores, petrol bunks, will probably be allowed to work one or two days a week – but governments have to evolve a mechanism whereby people don’t crowd them all at once, like the ration shops. Simply because India has far more family operated stores unlike the West, where the large supermarkets have replaced these in huge numbers, we don’t have the same problems, until now.

Similarly personal care services like barbershops, beauty salons, small clinics, laundry services, will also have to open at least on a trial basis. Since these involve personal contact, and great risk of spread, they may actually take quite a while to be allowed.

When eventually other services are allowed to reopen, they will all need phased reopening and closing, and operation time. Absence of public and very limited private transport will be a nightmare. 

Every service is dependent on a large network of other services, most of which is impossible to comprehend by an individual, or even an institution like a company or a government. This will be a logistical challenge of gigantic proportions, with no protocols, no training, a scared public, and a bureaucracy and security apparatus with no training for such challenges. Communicating a lot of these will be a huge challenge for Indians. We have a large workforce of computer programmers, people managers, event managers, logistic coordinators  and communicators, most of whom are working from home now. Perhaps they can be of good help in these upcoming challenges.

Crowding at Koyambedu bus stand
A Microsoft memory (in Tamil)

Additional Pictures
Almost all pictures taken from internet
Athletes light lamps on April 5

Soldiers in Siachen light lamps April 5

People clapping on Balconies March 23

Crowding at the Koyambedu intercity Bus terminus, Madras
March 24
Bad signalling, lack of planning


Thursday, 20 August 2015

எண்ணெழுத்தும் கையெழுத்தும்

தும்மல் இருமலை கூட விடாமல் படமெடுத்து நாம் இணையத்தில் பகிர்ந்துகொள்ளும் காலமிது. இது காமெரா கூடிய செல்பேசி புரட்சியின் பெரும் விளைவு. நான் பள்ளி கல்லூரி நாட்களிலும் அலுவலகம் சென்று வேலை செய்த காலத்திலும் காமெரா வாங்கிக்கொள்ளவில்லை. வேறொருவர் தயவிலோ காமெராவிலோ பதிந்தால் அதிசயம். 

இப்படி எதேச்சையாக சில படங்களை டெக்ஸாஸில் படித்தபோது எடுத்துக்கொண்டேன். ஃபில்ம் கேமெரா தான். தம்பி ஜெயராமன் வற்புறுத்தலில் ஒரு காமெரா வாங்கி பிற்காலத்தில் சியாட்டிலிலும் ஸான் ஹோஸேவிலும் வேலை பார்த்த காலத்தில் ஒரு சில படங்களை எடுத்துக்கொண்டேன். வீட்டிலும், இயற்கை சூழ்ந்த மலை நதி காடு போன்ற சுற்றுலா தலங்களில் தான் எடுத்துக்கொண்ட படங்கள். 

1993 இல் டெக்ஸாஸ் ஏ&எம்  பல்கலைகழகத்தில்
ஆனால் ஐந்து வருடங்களாக மாமா வரதராஜனும் மாமி பிரபாவும் கொடுத்த காமெராக்களில் டிஜிட்டல் படமெடுத்து கணினி கஜானா நிரம்பி வழிந்து தள்ளாடுகிரது.

எதிர் காலத்தை பார்த்தே வாழ்ந்த அந்த நாட்களில் நிகழ்காலத்தை பதிவு செய்யும் ஆவல் ஏனோ இல்லை. இப்பொழுது வருந்துகிறேன். அவ்வப்பொழுது என் தந்தை ரங்கரத்தினம் தமிழிலும், மிக சிறப்பாக ஆங்கிலத்திலும் பொது மேடைகளிலும் நீதிமன்றத்திலும் விவேகானந்தா கல்லூரியிலும் புகழ்ந்து சிலாகித்து பிரமித்து அவ்வுரைகளை கேட்டவர் சொல்லும்பொழுது, நாம் கேட்கவில்லையே என்று ஒரு சோகம் எழும். ஒலிப்பதிவுகளோ ஒளிப்பதிவுகளோ இல்லையே என்று மற்றொரு ஏக்கம். பள்ளிக்காலத்தில் பலமுறை சென்னை உயர்நீதிமன்றம் சென்றுள்ளேன், ஆனால் அவர் வாதாடி கேட்டதில்லை. அவருடை ஜுனியர் வழக்கறிஞர் லக்ஷ்மிநாராயணனின் மகனின் திருமணத்தில் ஒருவர் அவரது ஒரு சொற்பொழிவின் ஒலிநாடா இருப்பதாகவும், எனக்கு தருவதாகவும் சொன்னார்; அதன் பின் அவரை பார்க்கவே இல்லை. எங்கு தேடுவது. ஒரே ஒரு முறை தான் அரைகுறையாக மதறாஸ் உயர்நீதிமன்றத்தில் வக்கீல் உடையில் அவருடைய படத்தை எடுத்துக்கொண்டேன். ஆனந்த விகடனில் ஆத்ரேயன் என்ற புனைப்பெயரில் அவர் 1950-60 இல் ஒரு சிறுகதை எழுதினாராம். எங்கே எப்படி தேடுவது? என் அம்மாவும் பல கதைகள் எழுதினார் என்று அவர் அக்கா ஜெயலக்ஷ்மி போன வருடம் கூறினார். ஒன்றும் இன்று இல்லை.


மேடைகளில் தந்தை ரங்கரத்தினம்


விவேகானந்தா கல்லூரி மாணவர்களுன், என் தந்தை

கையெழுத்து

சமீபத்தில் அமெரிக்கா சென்ற போது எதையோ இணையத்தில் தேட, திடீரென்று நானும் அணில்வேலை செய்த MS SQL Server ஸீக்வெல் ஸெர்வர் மென்பொருளின் வரலாறை பற்றிய ஒரு இணையதளத்தை காண நேர்ந்தது. குழுவினர் படம் இல்லை. ஆனால், குழுவினர் கை எழுத்து பதித்த அட்டை பெட்டியின் படமிருந்தது. அதில் ஓரத்தில் என் கையெழுத்தும் கண்டு சிலிக்கான்பூதெய்தினேன். அடடா, நான் கூட வேலை செய்ததற்கு சான்றுள்ளதே! வாழ்க மைக்ரோஸாஃப்ட்டின் ஆவண ஆர்வம்! சந்ததி என்றோ உருவானால் இதாவது மிஞ்சும்.

Microsoft SQL Server 6.5 - அடியில் மங்கலாக என் கையெழுத்து

Microsoft SQL Server 6.0 -
வலது ஓரத்தில் என் கையெழுத்து


சில பெயர்களின் குறிப்புகள் 

ரான் சூக்கப் - Ron Soukup - குழுத் தலைவர்
பாப் ஹேய்ஸ் - Bob Hayes - நெருங்கி பழகிய நண்பர்
அம்ரீஷ் குமார் - Amrish Kumar - 6.5 இல் என் மேனேஜர்
சமீத அகர்வால் - S Agarwal - ஒரு வருடம் வீடு பகிர்ந்துகொண்ட roommate
மைக் ஹாப்பன், க்ரிஸ் கஸெல்லா, ஸ்ரீகுமார், லாலி திவ்ரிங்கி, கேவின் ஜன்கி - முக்கிய மென்பொருள் பொறியாளர்கள்
பீட்டர் ஹஸ்ஸி - Peter Hussey- குழுவை விட்டு விலகும் போது போகாதே நான் வேறு வேலை தருகிறேன் என்று கேட்டவர்!
ஹெய்டி க்ரௌர் - Heidi Krauer - secretary - செயலாளர்
6.0 மேனேஜர் கார்ல் ஜான்சன், வழிகாட்டி மற்றும் நல்ல நண்பர் மைக் பைத்தர் கையெழுத்துக்களை காணவில்லை, பெட்டியின் வேறுபுறம் இருக்கவேண்டும்.

உயிரெழுத்தா எண்ணெழுத்தா மென்பொருளா?

எழுத்தை எண்ணாக்கி, எண்ணை மின்னாக்கி செயல்படுவது மென்பொருள். Software ஸாஃப்ட்டுவேர் என்ற ஆங்கில சொல்லின் கவிநயமும் தமிழெழிலும் அன்றி மொழியாக்கிய சொல். Hardware, software - வணிகவழியே சிந்திக்கும் ஆங்கில சொற்கள் இவை என்று சொல்கிறார் நகுபோலியன். ஸமஸ்கிருதத்தில் Hardware ஸ்தூலம் என்றும் Software ஸூக்ஷமம் என்றும் சொல்லாடவேண்டும் என்பது அவர் கருத்து. கணினியின் மெய்ப்பொருள் ஹார்டுவேர், உயிரெழுத்து ஸாஃப்ட்டுவேர். எண்ணெழுத்து என்றாலும் தகும்.


தொடர்புடைய கட்டுரைகள்