Showing posts with label medicine. Show all posts
Showing posts with label medicine. Show all posts

Sunday, 16 May 2021

செவிலியர்க்கு பல்லாண்டு

மெய்யத்து மலையான் 
படம்: அஷோக் கிருஷ்ண்சாமி


பல்லாண்டு பல்லாண்டு பல்லாயி ரத்தாண்டு  பலகோடி நூறாயிரம்

மல்லாண்ட நலிமேனி குணம்பேணும் தொண்டர்க்கு பல்லாண்டு பல்லாண்டு


படியாமல் நோய்பிரிய புண்ணார பணிவோர்க்கு பல்லாண்டு

வடிவாய் திருவாய் இருவிதழில் மலர்கின்ற புன்சிரிப்பும் பல்லாண்டு

பொடியாய் நோய் தீர்க்கும் வல்லாயுத  நல்லூசியும் பல்லாண்டு 

விடிவாய் எழும் பகலாய் சுகம்தரும் சேவையும் பல்லாண்டே



Sunday, 3 January 2021

A brief timeline of Vaccinations

I am neither a doctor, nor biologist, nor historian. I first studied this for a lecture about Vaccination in Madras, for the Madras Local History Group. I have merely provided some dates and data, for an easier read.

Ignaz Semmelweiss


Before Sterilization and Germ theory

  • 1700s Lady Montague inoculates her children in Turkey, introduces vaccination to England
  •     English aristocrats inoculate their children
  • 1794 Edward Jenner starts variolation and vaccination
  • 1858 Great Stink of London, Thames cleaning begins
  •     Darwin-Wallace paper on Evolution presented by Lyell and Hooker
  •     Five of Darwin's children died in infancy (did vaccination not save them?)
  • 1864 Louis Pasteur discovers Germs cause diseases
  •     Antibodies, white blood cells discovered
  • 1847 Ignaz Semmelweiss discovers importance of sterilization, in Austria
  • 1848-1860 Political Turmoil in Europe
  • 1861 Semmelweiss campaigns for doctors to wash hands between surgeries
  •     Doctors refuse to wash hands, blood stains seen as symbols of valour
  • 1865 Semmelweiss sentenced and imprisoned in a lunatic asylum, for his sterilization campaign; dies 

After discovery of Sterilization

  • 1865 Lister advises Wash hands, use gloves, introduces anti-septics
  • 1860 John Snow discovers feces infested water causes cholera, campaigns for clean water. 
  •     John Snow: "Boil water before drinking"
  • 1861 Death by typhoid of Prince Albert, husband of Queen Victoria
  •     Campaign to clean up River Thames, London, build sewerage system
  • 1861 Europeanization of toilets, sewers.
  •     Globalization takes another century

Vaccination Laws in England

  •     1840 Free Vaccination
  •     1855 Compulsory Vaccination
  •     1867 Penalty to resist Vaccination

  • 1870 Robert Hooker: "Wallace has lost caste" (because Wallace explored spirituality, seances. Wallace also doubts that human mind evolved by Natural Selection)
  • 1890 Robert Koch : Different germs cause different diseases
  • 1896 Alfred Russel Wallace publishes book "Vaccination a Delusion, its penal enforcement a crime"
(This book by Wallace is out of print. A free version is available on Kindle, but very badly formatted)

I now suspend the timeline for some notes from Wallace's book

Wallace findings

  • Jenner: Less than 2000 deaths upto 1800
  • Parliament 1836: 5000 deaths before 1800
  • Dr Ernest Hart British Medical Journal 1880: 18,000 deaths per million
  • National Vaccination Society 1884: Before vaccination, 40,000 dead in England of pox
  • Wallace quip: "Dead were multiplying in the past"

Wallace observations

  • Villages and small towns rarely had deaths. Also far lower death rates than London
  • Filth diseases caused by foul air and water, decaying organic matter, overcrowding
  • Plague and leprosy not eliminated by vaccines but by marginal improvements in hygiene
  • Replaced by cholera, small pox etc as main killers
  • No careful tests were made with two groups one vaccinated, the other not
  • Doctors are bad statisticians
  • Royal Commission had no statisticians, but doctors, lawyers and politicians

Fortunately, unlike Semmelweiss, Wallace was not hounded into a lunatic asylum

(Gopu comment: Cheap cotton textiles, mainly imported from India via several East India Companies, from 1640 onwards, probably played a big role in improving European hygiene. As did the Cotton revolution in England from 1740 onwards.

Also cheaper coal because of James Watt engine made hot water far far cheaper. Average Europeans could bathe in winter almost as often as residents of tropics)

The Timeline continues...

PreModern Era of Medicine

  • 1890 German company Bayer invents Aspirin. Era of chemical medicine, pills, pharmaceutical industry begins
  • Insulin discovered
  • 1930s  Heroin, cocaine, all kinds of snake oil sold over the counter in USA
Modern Era of medicine
  • 1940 Sulfa, Antibiotics make Western medicine better than medicine of other nations for the first time in history (warning: this is only Gopu's opinion) 
  • Rate of decline of death rates go from 2% per year to 8% per year, some of it is credited to vaccines
  • 1945 Transistor invented. Integrated circuits follow soon. Electronic devices make research and medicine far superior in a short time
  • 1954 Polio vaccine invented
  • 1960 Measles mumps rubella (MMR) vaccine invented (Estimate 5000 deaths prevented in 20 years)
  • 1970 Smallpox eradicated
  • 1994 Plague suspected in Surat, Gujarat, India cut off from world for two weeks
  • 2000s Potential epidemics SARS, Ebola, swine flu, bird flu, curtailed before pandemic
  • 2020 January - COVID-19 Coronavirus epidemic in Wuhan, China; parts of Italy, USA; several air travelers
  • 2020 March - Global lockdowns begin
  • 2019 November - Announcements of several COVID-19 vaccines, from UK, USA, Russia, China

Explanatory Note

A small but vocal anti-vaccination movement is active in USA. Wikipedia calls is vaccine hesitancy. But such movements have been common throughout history, not just against vaccination, but against other new forms of medicine or science. Science usually wins, but frequently, what was considered turns out to be very unscientific - examples are : the four humours, phlogistons, phrenology, eugenics, vital forces theory, philosophers stone, Lysenko genetics, and possibly string theory.  Some of these people are extremely unscientific, religious (usually Christian - in the USA), some simply are suspicious of governments and doctors. 

If he were alive today, Alfred Wallace would also be labeled anti-vax and "denier". As his colleague Robert Hooker noted, "Wallace had lost caste."

Make of it what you will

Related Links

On Alfred Russel Wallace    

My essays on Biology 

Darwin's medical problems - and lousy medical treatment

Video of my lecture Vaccination in Madras (for Madras Local History)

Wednesday, 18 March 2020

பாட்டியை மூஞ்சில் குத்து



ஹான்ஸ் ரோஸ்லிங் (Hans Rosling) எனும் பொருளியல் வல்லுனர் எழுதிய ஃபாக்ட்ஃபுல்நஸ் Factfulness (செழுந்தகவல்) நூலை படித்துக்கொண்டிருக்கிறேன். கற்றோரும், சான்றோரும், பொருளியல் வல்லுனரும், பலநாட்டு தலைவர்களும், ஆய்வாளர்களும், விஞ்ஞானிகளும், இன்றைய உலகை எவ்வளவு தவறாக புரிந்துகொண்டுள்ளனர் என்று பக்கம்பக்கமாக விவரிக்கிறார். 

வளர்ந்தநாடு வளரும்நாடு எனும் இருவகை பிரிவு 1940களில் உருவாகியது. அந்த நிலமை மாறி நாற்பது வருடங்களாகிவிட்டன. இன்று உலக நாடுகளை செல்வத்தாலும் வளர்ச்சியாலும் மக்கள் நலத்தாலும் நான்கு வகையாய் –இரண்டு வகையாக அல்ல - பிரிக்கவேண்டும் என்று 1999 முதல் உலகின் பல அரங்குகளில் சொல்லி வருகிறார். நோபல் பரிசு வழங்கும் ஸ்வீடன் நாட்டின் கரோலின்ஸ்கா கல்லூரிக்கே இதை புரியவைக்க அவருக்கு பல வருடங்கள் ஆனது.

நூலின் ஒன்பதாம் அத்தியாயத்தில், ஒர் சம்பவம் சொல்கிறார். இந்த அத்தியாயத்தின் பெயர் “பழி வீசும் இயல்பு”.

என் மொழியாக்கம் கீழே.

பழி வீசும் இயல்பு

நான் கரோலின்ஸ்கா கல்லூரியில் பந்நாட்டு மருந்து கம்பெனிகளை பற்றி பாடம் நடத்தி கொண்டிருந்தேன். வருமையான நாடுகளில் மட்டும் நிலவும் மலேரியா, உறக்கநோய் போன்ற நோய்களை ஒழிக்க, பணக்கார பந்நாட்டு கம்பெனிகளில்  ஆராய்ச்சி ஏதும் நடத்துவதில்லை என்று விளக்கினேன்.

முன் வரிசையிலுள்ள ஒரு மாணவன், “அவர்களை மூஞ்சிலேயே குத்தவேண்டும்” என்றான்.

“ஆகா”, என்றேன். “சில நாட்களில் நான் சுவிட்சர்லாண்டிலுள்ள நோவார்டிஸ் எனும் கம்பெனிக்கு உரையாற்ற செல்வேன். யாரை குத்த வேண்டும், குத்தி என்ன சாதிப்பேன் என்று விளக்கினால், நான் போய் குத்திவிட்டு வருகிறேன்.”

“இல்லை, இல்லை. அவர்கள முதலாளியை குத்தவேண்டும்.”

“சரி. கம்பெனி முதலாளி டேனியல் வசெல்லா. அவரை சந்திப்பேன். அவரை மூஞ்சில் குத்தவா? குத்தியதனால் மலேரியா ஆராய்ச்சி தொடங்க ஆணையிடுவாரா?”

பின்னிருக்கையிலிருந்து வேறொரு மாணவன் வாய்மலர்ந்தான். “கம்பெனி நிர்வாக இயக்குனர்கள் அனைவரையும், மூஞ்சில் குத்தவேண்டும்.”

“நிச்சயம் செய்யலாம். அன்று மதியம் நிர்வாக இயக்குனர்கள் சிலரை சந்திப்பேன். காலையில் டேனியல் தப்பித்தார். மதியம் ஒரு ரவுண்டு கட்டி மற்றவரை சுழட்டி சுழட்டி மூஞ்சில் குத்துகிறேன். அனைவரையும் குத்தும் வரை என் கூந்தலில் தேங்காய் எண்ணெய் தடவாதிருப்பேன், ரிப்பன் போடமாட்டேன், அன்னை பராசக்தி மேல் ஆணை. ஆனால் நான் வயதானவன், மல்லனோ சண்டியனோ அல்ல, நாலைந்து நபரை குத்தியபின் அங்குள்ள காவலர்கள் என்னை பின்னி பெடலெடுக்கலாம். சரி இதனால் என்ன மாறும்? நான் கொடுத்த குத்தில் தான் செய்த பாவம் அறிந்து, சித்தம் தெளிந்து, சிந்தை குளிர்ந்து, மெய்ஞ்ஞானம் பெற்ற கம்பெனி இயக்குனர்கள் மலேரிய ஆய்வை மேற்கொள்வாரா?”

“இல்லை இல்லை, நோவார்ட்டிஸ் ஒரு தனியார் கம்பெனியல்ல. பங்கு சந்தையில் அந்த கம்பெனி பங்குகளை யார் வேண்டுமானாலும் வாங்கலாம். பங்காளிகள் தான் அந்த கம்பெனியின் உண்மை முதலாளிகள்,” என்றான் ஒளிபடைத்த கண்ணனாம் மூன்றாம் மாணவன்.

“பலே பாண்டியா! சரியாக சொன்னாய். இந்த கம்பெனியின் பங்குதார்ரகளே மலேரிய ஆராய்ச்சியை விரும்பாமல் செல்வந்தர் நோய் மட்டுமே தீர்த்து பணம் சம்பாதிப்பதில் குறியாய் வெறியாய் நரியாய் அரியாய் உள்ளனர். யாரிந்த குறி வெறி நரிகள்?” என்றேன்.

“பணக்காரர்கள்.” என்றான் முன் வரிசை மைக் டைசன்.

“அது தானில்லை. மருந்து கம்பெனிகளின் வருமானம் கச்சா எண்ணெய் கம்பெனிகளின் வருமானம் போல வளர்ந்தும் தேய்ந்தும் ஊஞ்சலாடா. வருடாவருடம் பெரிதாக ஏறியிறங்காமல் நம்பகமாக லாபம் பெற்று, துல்லியமாக பங்குதாரர்களுக்கு பங்கு தருகின்றன. அதனால் இவற்றில் முதலீடு போடுவதும் சில நிதி நிறுவனங்களே. பங்குகளை வாங்கி பலவருடங்கள் விற்காமல் தக்கவைத்து கொள்ளும். அவை யார் யார் என்று தெரியுமா?” என்று கேட்டேன்.

மாணவர்களுக்கு இந்த பங்கு சந்தை விவரம் தெரிந்திருக்கவில்லை. சுட்ட நாவல் பழத்தை கேட்ட அவ்வையை போல் என்னை ஆவலுடன் நோக்கினர்.

“ஓய்வூதிய நிதி நிறுவனங்கள் (Retirement funds)” என்றேன். மயான நிசப்தம்.

“அந்த மாதிரி நிதி நிறுவனங்களில் பங்கு வாங்கியுள்ள வயோதிகரை நான் சந்திக்க வாய்ப்பில்லை. ஆனால் நீங்கள் உங்கள் பாட்டியை வாராவாரம் சந்திப்பவராக இருந்தால் இந்த வாரம் உங்க பாட்டி மூஞ்சில் குத்தலாம். சுயநலாமாக தங்களுக்கு மாதாந்திர வருமானம் ஆடாமல் அசையாமல் அள்ளி வரவேண்டும் எனும் ஆர்வத்தில், பணக்காரர்களின் நோய்களுக்கு மட்டும் மருந்து தேடும் ஆராய்ச்சி கம்பெனிகளின் உண்மை முதலாளிகள் அவர்களே.

“மேலும். சமீபத்தில் நீங்கள் ஊர்சுற்றவோ விழா கொண்டாடவோ உங்களுக்கு உங்கள் பாட்டி ஏதேனும் அன்பளிப்பாக கொஞ்சம் பணம் குடுத்திருந்தால் உங்கள மூஞ்சையும் கொஞ்சம் குத்திக்கலாம்.”

மொழியாக்கம் முற்றும்.

என் குறிப்பு : ஓய்வுபெற்றவர்களின் நிதிகளை கையாண்டு, மாதாமாத ஓய்வு வருமானத்தை தவிற, கொஞ்சம் பங்கு சந்தையில் போட்டால் நல்ல வருமானம் கிடைக்கலாம் என்பதால் சில நிறுவனங்கள் அவர்கள் உபரி செல்வத்தில் இந்த மாதிரி கம்பெனிகளில் பங்கு வாங்கி, வருடத்திற்கு மூன்றுநான்கு முறை அவர்களுக்கு பணம்பெற்று தருகின்றன.

ஹான்ஸ் ரோஸ்லிங் பேசும் வீடியோ காட்சி

Friday, 15 April 2016

Madras and it's American connections

Mr S Muthiah gave a lecture on Madras and its American connection, at CP Ramaswami Aiyar Foundation, Alwarpet, Madras on April 9, 2016. Muthiah's birthday was on April 13 - two days back; by coincidence, I reviewed Mr Narasiah's book, Madrasapattinam, for which Mr Muthiah has written the foreword, that evening.

The connection started long before the founding of the USA, he said. He covered the period from colonial America to the recent establishment of the Roja Muthiah Research Library in Taramani.

He started with Elihu Yale, Governor of Madras for the East India Company and the obelisk in Madras Law College. Yale married the widow Catherine of his friend Joseph Hymner, then sent her off to England; he then had two rich widows living with him.

There was an enquiry into his wealth. He managed to avoid the enquiry, which  was conducted in his absence. But he was acquitted. He acquired a large collection of arts with his wealth. He donated two trunks of textiles and a trunk of paintings and artifacts which were auctioned for 1200 pounds to the Collegiate School of Connecticut, which named itself Yale college; later this became Yale University. If 1200 pounds seems a small founding amount, remember that John Harvard donated 1100 pounds to the college named after him, quipped Mr Muthiah.

A sailing ship called United States was the first American ship to visit India. The most popular export from Madras was bandanas - which became the signature fashion statement of American cowboys. Second in popular was the Madras handkerchief, still a major Madras export in the 21st century, but now the major market is West Africa.

As a gift for losing America to rebels at Yorktown, Cornwallis was made Governor General of India. He launched the third Mysore war with Tipu, holding his sons as hostages.

The US consulate building in Madras, at Gemini, was inspired by Chettinad architecture, which had a murram in center. Earlier the Consulate functioned from what is now Dare House in Parry's corner, he said. Benjamin Joy was the first American consul in Calcutta, but he tried to establish a trading post.

The Americans mostly left political affairs to Britain until India became a republic. In 1950 the Indo-American association was formed. A sister city link was established with Denver, but nothing materialized besides politicians from each city touring the other.

Christian Missionaries and Medicine

John Scudder and Myron Winslow, American allopathic doctors, came to serve as missionaries in Sri Lanka. Ida Scudder his granddaughter established Christian medical college, Vellore. Winslow collaborated with Arumuga Navalar to produce first  Tamil to English dictionary with 68,000s word in 1862.
Scudder Winslow and Green

The remarkable Samuel Fisk Green, from Worcester Massachusetts, translated medical books into Tamil and taught Jaffna Tamil boys who became better doctors than English-taught Colombo boys. There is a hospital in Jaffna named after him. None of the political parties in Tamilnadu which wear Tamil linguistic pride on their sleeves has continued Green's efforts. Allopathic medicine continues to be taught entirely in English in TN.

In 1883. Col Henry Olcott, Civil  War veteran and Helena Blavatsky , a Russian countess, formed the Theosophical society. Blavatsky dreamed of a river bank, could not find such a river in Bombay, then spotted the Adyar river in Madras and decided it was perfect for the society.

Olcott built finest Indology library with twenty thousand palm leaves and two lakh books. Olcott, an ardent student of Buddhism in South east Asia, revived Buddhism in Sri Lanka which was almost dead. Coupled with Green's work in Jaffna, they created the civil strife in Sri Lanka, opined Muthiah.

Cotton and Ice

Tirunelveli was the major cotton growing district in Madras Presidency. In 1830 Madras government brought Bernard Metcalfe from USA and introduced cotton gins. Gins were a failure because no laborer was willing to work with machines , they preferred their hands. Thomas James Finnie came with planters to plant American cotton but realised that only Indian cotton plants grew well here. Robert White developed an Indian cotton in Coimbatore. The American civil war, cut off cotton supplies from the South - the Confederacy - and India filled the supply in this period.

Ice ships from Walden pond, packed in felt and sawdust, 80% were exported to Madras Bombay and Calcutta. Thoreau has written about it. Icebergs from Newfoundland were chopped up for export, when Massachusetts was too warm for ice. The Ice trade went on for a hundred years, 150 tons each year for three metros. Ice House, now the Vivekananda Illam in Triplicane, was the only building with an American flag in the city.

Ice ponds in Massachussets

US postmaster general Wannamaker donated of forty thousands dollars to construct the YMCA building in Madras. Harry Crowe Buck of Springfield, MA introduced physical education, volleyball and basketball to Madras. India's Olympic program owes everything to Harry Crowe Buck.


YMCA, Harry Buck - speaker Muthiah

The Jaffna American missionaries built American College in Madurai. In beating the heat of Madurai in the summer, the found Ooty was too snooty. So they established Kodaikanal.

In 1907 Henry Phipps started Pasteur institute in Connoor by donating one lakh dollars to Lord Curzon. At this time there was only one Pasteur institute in North India and supplies of vaccines and serums to south were sparse. Their role in the eradication of  rabies was invaluable.

In 1911 Chandler added to and compiled a Tamil dictionary, based on Winslow dictionary. He produced Tamil Lexicon now 82,000 words. Later Vaiyapuri Pillai took it up.

In 1915 WCC, the Women's christian college was founded, with funds from Rockefeller. The Founding records are in Mt Holyoke College in the USA on which it was based.

Scudder (a descendant of Ira Scudder who set up CMC Vellore) and Rottschaeffer, set up the tuberculosis sanatorium in Madanapalle. Dr Janeway set up pediatric ward in Madras.

Films and Factories

Most famous is Ellis Dungan, an American film director, who lived in Madras for fifteen years and directed several Tamil movies. He introduced camera and lighting techniques. Two of his movies starred with M.S.Subbulakshmi - Meera and Sakuntalai. He also directed Mandirikumari starring MGR, for which the script was written by M Karunanidhi, both of whom went on to become Chief Minsiters of Tamilnadu.



Ellis Dungan and MS Subbulakshmi

The Ford company built a plant in Bombay in 1916 but shut it down in the 1950s. Ford trucks were manufactured in Madras, in a collaboration with  Amalgamations, but this was a failure. But Ford came back in 1996 set up a plant to make cars on GST Road. They scouted several locations, but the clinching  factor was dinner in the Madras club!

Earliest freedom fighters - against British rule - including Sikhs granted asylum in USA. Franklin Roosevelt urged Churchill to grant India independence.

The American Consul was in attendance at the lecture.

Related blogs
Madras - India's first modern city - S Muthiah lecture
The Thames and the Cooum
An evening with John and Pamela Davis 
Paul Erdos' poem on Madras 
Ford, Lenin, Hitler and Chaplin 
America the Beautiful

Thursday, 21 May 2015

உழவர் தற்கொலை

சுவாமிநாத ஐயர் டைம்ஸ் ஆஃப் இந்தியா பத்திரிகையில் பொருளியல் கட்டுரைகளை எழுதிவருபவர். இடதுசாரி எண்ணங்கள் பரவலாயுள்ள இந்திய நாளிதழ் சூழலில் தெளிவாக வலதுசாரி சிந்தனைகளை முன்வைப்பவர். பல வருடங்களாக இவரை படித்து வருகிறேன். பொருளியல் பார்வையில் சமூகத்தை அலசி, புதிதாக பல தகவல்களை சொல்வார். இந்தியாவில் இது செவிடன் காதில் சங்கு ஊதும் பிழைப்பு. இந்த கட்டுரை பிடித்ததாலும், உழவர் தற்கொலைகளை பற்றி புலம்பல்களே அதிகம் இருப்பதாலும், நான் இதை தமிழில் மொழிபெயர்த்து இங்கு பகிர்கிறேன். இதன் ஆங்கில மூலம் இங்கே

Tuesday, 28 April 2015

Darwin and his doctor

After his voyage (1831-1836) on the ship HMS Beagle, when he sailed around the world studying and learning about biology and geology, Charles Darwin, settled down in England and wrote the book the Voyage of the Beagle. It was a bestseller, as far as travel narratives went, and inspired later explorers like Alfred Russel Wallace to also travel to South America.

Darwin spent the next twenty years gathering material from across the world, communicating with botanists and zoologists and collectors and experts in various other fields. He had formed the outline for the theory of speciation and his proposal for its mechanism - natural selection; but he kept it secret. But he made a significant reputation as a geologist, writing a major book on coral reefs. His explanation of the slow elevation of the landmass of South America - he had seen fossils of marine creatures high up in the Andes - was enthusiastically welcomed by his mentor and new friend in Geology, Charles Lyell. Darwin had taken Lyell's book Principle of Geology, on his voyage and it had helped him understand biology in a way no one else previously could.

In the meanwhile, in the 1840s, one of his friends asked him to study barnacles, and explain them since there was such confusion about them. Darwin estimated it would take him a month. It took him eight years.

This fascinating side-track to his researches is beautifully narrated in a book, Darwin and the Barnacle, by Rebecca Stott. I have been going to the Anna Centennial Library in Kotturpuram, Madras, for the past few weeks and reading this book. This library is a treasure house of wonderful books on all subjects and one of my great delights has been reading Wallace’s books there, among others. But this time, Darwin.

What fascinated me about this book, were two lateral matters : Darwin’s medical treatment and his fiscal situation. Darwin was a frequently sick person, suffering from several ailments of the stomach. He suffered terribly through his ocean voyages. Land did not improve things. But he was receiving barnacles by email, dissecting barnacles, discussing barnacles, occasionally going to the sea to collect barnacles, discovering new species of barnacles, getting confused by their variety and bizarreness. For a while barnacles were his only pleasure, besides his children.

Darwin's Water Cure

Dr James Gully, who was recommended by the poet Alfred, Lord Tennyson, an acquaintance of  Darwin, had some severe but effective methods treatment. One was the wet-wrap ; a wet sheet wrapped tightly around his body, almost like an Egyptian mummy.

Another was the douche, a French word meaning shower. But this was no simple shower. A 640 gallon water tank was install on a stage in an outhouse of Darwin’s house – this let out water through a two inch pipe. This may not sound like much to those of us who have been soaked in the waterfalls like Courtallam or Papanasam or Ambasamudram, but Darwin lived in much colder England. One must also remember that modern plumbing system, with piped water, hot and cold, had not been invented yet.

The freakiest treatment Darwin underwent, was lamp baths. We don’t associate lamps with baths! How do you bathe with a lamp? In this system, one sat on a stool wrapped in towels with a lamp under the stool getting warmer and warmer, until suddenly sweat poured down like a torrent. This sounds more like cooking than curing!

To top it all, Dr Gully’s water cure included
1.     Homeopathy
2.     Mesmerism
3.     Hydropathy
Gully’s philosophy was that the body's "natural energies" would cure itself. 

Allopathic (Western medicine) doctors today consider these to be nothing but quackery, with no scientific basis whatsoever. Think about the irony of this : the world’s most famous biologist was treated by a famous London doctor by methods that are laughed at today. Of such episodes is made the history relevant to the common man, more than the wars and wealth and the romances of rulers and armies.

It was only in the next few decades that such standard practices such as sterilization, the importance of clean water, chemical pills etc were discovered. And the invention of antibiotics had to wait until the Second World War.

A later story is illuminating. American President James Garfield was shot by an assassin. The doctors tried to extract a bullet by using their bare fingers! He died two months later, most likely by infection. The shooter was hanged for assassination, even though, it is quite possible that it was the doctors’ unsterilized probing that mostly killed Garfield. Closer home, V Krishnaswamy Iyer of Madras, died of a septic infection when the medal pinned on him in the 1911 Delhi Durbar by King George the Fifth pricked his skin! This would be cured by cheap medicine today.

Coming back to Darwin’s treatment. In addition, Dr Gully issued these orders.

No work
Minimal reading
No writing (except a few minutes a day)
No sugar, salt, rich foods stimulants alcohol or snuff.
Also forbidden : barnacles!

Stott writes that this ban on barnacles was the hardest thing Darwin had to bear. He was equally appalled at the ban on snuff, but his daughter Annie would occasionally smuggle it into his study, it seems!

Darwin used his writing allowance to write letters to collect barnacles from others!

The Curiosity of Englishmen

The sheer variety of collectors and enthusiasts is mind numbing, and gives an insight into the scientific spirit and curiosity of segments of England’s population of those times. If Britannia ruled the waves, it was not merely by military power, naval power or the business skills of its traders – these endeavors played a significant part in England’s significant role in the 19th century, which continues today.

James Bowerbank, London distillery owner and sponge collector sent Darwin barnacles attached to his sponges. Edward Forbes, banker and son of a timber merchant, followed Alexander the great's Asian route and discovered 18 buried cities! He explored sea creatures in Lycian coast, where Aristotle had once walked and wrote books on starfish and jelly fish , became professor of botany at King's college. Such brilliant collectors and the newly established efficient and dependable postal system (more on it later) were the substrate of infrastructure that helped Darwin become such a brilliant biologist. No wonder then, that several thoughtful Indians in the nineteenth century, welcomed British rule as benevolent and beneficent, a magnificent harness pulling India along into a glorious new scientific age.

Related Links

1. Rebecca Stott
2. A brief history of Surgery (video)
3. Alfred Russel Wallace (in Tamil)
4. The Thames and the Cooum
5. Pleasures of a Library